
Profitero+ today released its 10th annual Price Wars study, analyzing online prices for more than 18,000 products across 24 leading U.S. retailers.
The study found that competition has become particularly fierce across everyday essentials. With household budgets still under pressure, retailers are competing more aggressively for spending on frequently purchased products. The study also reveals and examines how those price differences are changing across specialist retailers (e.g., Pet Care, Beauty, and Drugstores, among others).
Price gaps are narrowing among the essentials
Beauty, packaged foods, and health and personal care all saw a narrowing of average price gaps versus the previous year. In Beauty, this narrowing showed up quite consistently across the retailers compared in the study.
Price trends vary depending on the category
In Pet Supplies, price gaps were relatively slim compared to the previous year. Video games showed much wider differences. One retailer, for example, saw considerable narrowing (between their prices and the best market prices) in 2025, with the gap widening this year and allowing competitors to gain ground.
Within categories, relative positions keep shifting
Fashion and Drugstore companies saw their relative price positions shift. Among drugstores, one retailer ousted another from its previous position (first within the category) as their price gaps moved in opposing directions.
“A decade into this report, price remains key to where consumers shop,” said Ethan Goodman, President of Profitero+. “As household budgets tighten, being competitive doesn’t mean being cheapest on every product. Retailers and brands need to understand where price matters most to consumers and have the data and agility to respond.”
Based on data rounded to whole percentages. Only identical items available and in-stock in the same pack configuration were compared. Data was collected daily over 12 weeks (July 6 - Sep 27, 2026), with daily prices averaged over the full period for comparison. Prices for the same items were collected within 24 hours of each other to ensure validity of the comparisons. To refer to past Profitero+ Price Wars studies, please go to: www.profitero.com/resources.
Retailers featured in the study included mass-market retailers and specialists in beauty, pet supplies, video games, health and wellness, fashion, home improvement, and other categories.
